Carl Bender's Nintendo's Wii: more than the sum of its parts (editorial)

Tuesday 25th September 2007, 07:07:00 PM, written by Stefan Salzl

In a Beyond3D editorial our very own Carl Bender is offering a different view on the mainstream phenomena called 'Wii', following yesterday's blog cooperation with Newsweek's Level Up.

For him it's more than just a question of technology or a marketing effort. Read his insightful comments here.

Discuss on the forums

Tagging

wii ± nintendo, editorial,


Latest Thread Comments (136 total)
Posted by Shark Sandwich on Monday, 01-Oct-07 01:27:28 UTC
Quoting Joshua Luna
Based on their past purchases I get the feeling they will buy 2 games and... never buy another.
This brings up an interesting question. I wonder whether the type of consumers who have been snatching up all these Wii consoles like crazy will buy many games for it. I would love to see how many people bought a Wii and only have Wii Sports. It will be VERY interesting to see whether these "casual gamers" buy enough games to make the Wii a success for the game developers.

Wii is uncharted territory. There has never been a console that has depended on so-called "casual gamers" to the degree Wii does. You can't read a single thread about the Wii without hearing about how someone's parents, or grandma, or sister, or girlfriend has picked up a videogame for the first time because of the Wii.

I honestly think there is a very good chance that the Wii will have 2 "classes" of buyers: a. the "casual gamers" who buy 2-3 games and that's it, and b. the Nintendo fanatics who buy Nintendo consoles almost exclusively for the first-party games (in other words, the same group who bought the Gamecube and N64).

At any rate, the Wii is a great experiment, and I love it that I can sit back and watch the show unfold :)

Posted by StefanS on Monday, 01-Oct-07 06:22:24 UTC
Quoting Bohdy
The article states that there is 3.1MB of memory, but I don't remember the .1 ever being specified for the GCN.
Most people just forgot to mention it, but it's was there as well. The GCN had 2.1 MB of framebuffer plus 1MB texture cache.

Posted by Shifty Geezer on Monday, 01-Oct-07 07:17:04 UTC
Quoting Shark Sandwich
This brings up an interesting question. I wonder whether the type of consumers who have been snatching up all these Wii consoles like crazy will buy many games for it.
At the moment, the attach rate is supposedly >4. So that's either most people buying 3 or 4 games for their system, or a few people buying absolutely everything and everyone else just playing Wii Sports and Wii Play (obtained when they bought their second controller)Actually if Wii is all about social gaming, why doesn't it come with two controllers as standard?

Posted by Bohdy on Monday, 01-Oct-07 10:05:45 UTC
Quoting StefanS
Most people just forgot to mention it, but it's was there as well. The GCN had 2.1 MB of framebuffer plus 1MB texture cache.
Then why did GCN games render in 24-bit RGBA (banding galore bleh) when a 640x480*(32rgba+24z) buffer fits in 2.1MB?

Posted by .Melchiah. on Wednesday, 03-Oct-07 10:44:13 UTC
Quoting Shifty Geezer
Actually if Wii is all about social gaming, why doesn't it come with two controllers as standard?
Because that way Nintendo can charge for the extra controller.

Posted by Arwin on Wednesday, 03-Oct-07 11:51:39 UTC
Because everyone should own a Wii and then they can bring their own controller to which ever friend's house they are bringing the Wii. Duh. ;)

Also, they might not have been comfortable with a retail package over 300$/euro.

Posted by No.6 on Thursday, 04-Oct-07 22:25:06 UTC
Quoting Shifty Geezer
Actually if Wii is all about social gaming, why doesn't it come with two controllers as standard?
If the X360 is all about live gaming over the 'net, why doesn't it come with wireless networking? Easy: manufacturers tweak features to hit the price points they want.

It's not good or bad; just is.

IMO this article more than adequately proves that the Wii's popularity is not because of the console's raw power. I guess it really turns out that doing something (waving hand to bowl or swing a sword) is more enjoyable to many people than emulating something (pressing A to bowl or swing the sword).

In my case I opted for Wii because it is different, and I'm already into PC gaming for the high-rez high-fidelity stuff. If I'd grown up as a console gamer I'd probably choose X360 or PS3, but I'm not.

Posted by archangelmorph on Friday, 05-Oct-07 09:28:01 UTC
Quoting No.6
If the X360 is all about live gaming over the 'net, why doesn't it come with wireless networking?
:???:

Errr...

Because you can play online with a wired setup..?

Because wireless networking is slow(er)?

Because LIVE is only a subset of the vision the console stands for..?

Flawed counter-arguement i'd say..

Posted by jandar on Friday, 05-Oct-07 15:45:09 UTC
Quoting archangelmorph
:???:

Errr...

Because you can play online with a wired setup..?

Because wireless networking is slow(er)?

Because LIVE is only a subset of the vision the console stands for..?

Flawed counter-arguement i'd say..

Well you can buy another controller for the wii, probably cheaper than trying to buy and run a long network cable, or having someone drill your walls.

Even old 802.11b is faster than 10Mb cable can run

The wii controller is only a subset of the vision the console was made for. (ease of use, simple fun gaming, etc)


Its a valid counter argument.

Posted by archangelmorph on Friday, 05-Oct-07 15:51:50 UTC
Quoting jandar
Well you can buy another controller for the wii, probably cheaper than trying to buy and run a long network cable, or having someone drill your walls.
For starters a network cable will cost you about £5 pounds (30m) & it costs nothing to run it along the skirting boards or under the carpet..

Quoting jandar
Even old 802.11b is faster than 10Mb cable can run
Who uses ethernet slower than 100Mb/s these days?

Quoting jandar
The wii controller is only a subset of the vision the console was made for. (ease of use, simple fun gaming, etc)
The Wii controller is the absolute embodiment of the vision of the console.. without it do you honestly think the console would be where it is today..??

Quoting jandar
Its a valid counter argument.
Valid... But flawed..


Add your comment in the forums

Related wii News

E3 2008: Nintendo Press Conference Highlights
Wii get(s) 1:1 motion control
Wii reaches 5 million units threshold in Japan
NewsWeek, with a little help, takes on Wii as Gamecube 1.5
Gamebryo 2 Engine now available for the Wii
Wii outsells PS3 6-to-1 in Japan in June, 5-to-1 in May, 4-to-1 in April
Nintendo to sell new downloadable games
Nintendo's market capitalisation entered Japanese Top 10 for a brief while
Speech recognition middleware VoiceIn now available to Wii developers
Refining Wii accelerometer data with Kalman filtering